How matcha got so popular, and why good matcha is hard to find
Ten years ago a matcha latte was a curiosity. Now it is the green drink in every café window and a serious rival to coffee at our own counter in Tarrytown. Its rise has been fast, and in the way of fast things it has outrun the supply of the good stuff. Here is how a monastery tea became a global habit, what separates good matcha from the rest, and how to get a cup worth drinking.
Monks, bowls and a very old habit
Powdered tea came to Japan from China, where whisking ground tea into hot water was the fashion during the Song dynasty. The most-told version credits the Zen monk Eisai with bringing tea seeds and the practice back to Japan at the end of the twelfth century. Monks drank it to stay awake and clear-headed through long meditation, and that pairing of alertness and calm is still the thing people describe when they talk about matcha.
Over the following centuries the preparation of tea in Japan turned into something closer to a discipline. The tea ceremony, chanoyu, reached its mature form in the sixteenth century under the tea master Sen no Rikyū, with its emphasis on simplicity, attention and the quiet handling of a bowl. Matcha is the tea of that ceremony. China largely moved on to steeped leaf tea; Japan kept the whisk.
Uji, shade and the stone mill
The region most associated with matcha is Uji, south of Kyoto, where tea has been grown for centuries. Nishio, in Aichi, is the other classic name. What makes matcha different from an ordinary green tea begins in the field: for roughly three to four weeks before harvest the bushes are covered to block most of the sunlight. Shading pushes the plant to make more chlorophyll, which deepens the colour, and more L-theanine, the amino acid behind matcha's sweet, savoury depth and its gentle kind of alertness.
The shaded leaves are steamed to stop oxidation, dried, and stripped of stems and veins. At that stage the leaf is called tencha. Only when tencha is ground does it become matcha, and traditionally that is done on a granite stone mill turning slowly enough that the powder does not heat up. A mill produces a small amount per hour, which is one of the reasons good matcha has always been expensive and always will be.
How a monastery tea became a café drink
Matcha stayed mostly inside Japan until the 2000s. Then a few things happened at once. Western cafés were looking for a drink that could sit alongside the latte, and a frothy green one that photographed well was an obvious candidate. The wellness conversation found a tea with antioxidants and a long story of mindful use. And social media, especially once feeds went visual, did the rest. A matcha latte is one of the most recognisable drinks on earth now, and a great deal of that is simply the colour.
There is a real reason underneath the aesthetics. Matcha is the whole leaf, ground and swallowed, so you get more of what the leaf contains than you would from steeping. The caffeine arrives alongside L-theanine, and many people find the result steadier than coffee: alert without the edge. That is a widely reported experience rather than a guarantee, and the caffeine is still real, so treat it as a caffeinated drink.
The squeeze
Demand has recently outrun supply. Through 2024 and 2025 it has been widely reported that producers in Japan struggled to keep up, that some well-known names limited how much each customer could buy, and that prices climbed. The reasons given include a single annual spring harvest for the best grades, an ageing population of tea farmers, and a surge of international demand that nobody planted for a decade ago. We will not pretend to know how it resolves. What it means for a drinker is that the gap between good and poor matcha has widened, because a lot of product has rushed in to fill the shelf.
Good matcha is vivid, fine and sweet. If it is khaki, gritty or bitter, something went wrong before it reached the cup.
How to recognise good matcha
- Colour. Good matcha is a vivid, almost electric green. Yellowish, olive or khaki powder is either a lower grade, old, or both.
- Texture. It should be as fine as eyeshadow and cling to your fingertip. Coarse powder was ground fast or ground from the wrong leaf.
- Smell. Fresh, grassy and faintly sweet, like a cut lawn with something savoury under it.
- Taste. Sweet umami first, then a clean, light vegetal finish. A little astringency is normal; sandy bitterness is not.
- Froth. Whisked well in a little hot water, good matcha builds a fine, stable foam. Poor matcha sits in a thin, bubbly puddle.
Why so much of it disappoints
Most disappointing matcha falls into one of a few traps. The first is grade. Culinary matcha, meant for baking and ice cream where sugar and fat cover its flaws, is made from later harvests and less shade. It is fine in a cake and harsh in a cup. The second is age. Matcha is a ground powder with a huge surface area, and it oxidises quickly; a tin that has been open for months has lost its colour and gained bitterness. The third is handling. Light and air are its enemies, so clear jars and loose lids do real damage.
The fourth trap is in the making. Water just off the boil scorches matcha and pulls out the bitter notes; the traditional range is well below boiling. Too little whisking leaves lumps that taste like dust. And finally, a lot of café matcha is drowned in sweetener and syrup to hide all of the above. Sweet is not the same as good.
How to order it
At our counter we serve a Matcha Latte hot or iced, in 12 oz or 16 oz. The hot version is softer and shows the sweetness; the iced one is brighter and more vegetal, and is the better choice on a warm day in the Rivertowns. If you prefer it closer to the traditional bowl, ask about having it straight, with little or no milk, and ask how we prepare it. If you are curious how it compares to a steeped green tea, our teas from Harney & Sons include a Japanese Sencha, which is the same plant grown in full sun and steeped rather than whisked. Drinking them side by side is the quickest education in what shade and grinding do.
We will not make claims about grades and sources on a blog. What we will say is that matcha deserves the same attention we give to a phin coffee: good water, the right temperature, and a drink made for the person in front of us. Come in, order it the way you like it, and taste for yourself whether it is green enough.
