The power of a great chai, and what separates it from the rest
A chai latte ordered at random in America is a gamble. Sometimes it is a bright, peppery, properly spiced cup of tea with milk. More often it is a pump of sweet syrup in steamed milk, with the spices doing little more than naming the drink. The difference matters, because a real chai is one of the great drinks of the world, and it is worth knowing what you are looking for.
Where chai comes from
The word chai simply means tea in Hindi and in many other languages, descended from the Chinese chá. What English speakers usually mean by chai is masala chai: spiced tea, brewed strong with milk and sugar, the everyday drink of much of India.
Its history is shorter than people think, and more tangled. The most-told version traces spiced, warming infusions back to Ayurvedic kadha, decoctions of spices and herbs taken for health long before tea was involved. Tea itself was a British project. The East India Company began planting tea in Assam in the 1830s to break China's hold on the trade, and for most of the 1800s the crop was for export, not for Indians.
In the early 1900s the Indian Tea Association began pushing tea on the domestic market, setting up tea breaks in factories and stalls at railway stations. The vendors, the chai wallahs, did what the Association did not want: they stretched the expensive leaf with milk, sugar and spices so a cup could be cheap and still taste like something. Masala chai as a street drink grew from that economy. The spread of CTC tea from the 1960s, a machine-processed black tea that brews strong and fast, made it affordable for everyone, and it has set the daily rhythm of the subcontinent since.
What makes a chai great
Everyone has an opinion on this, from Mumbai to Tarrytown, but the great cups share a few things.
- Real tea, brewed strong. A chai starts as tea, and a strong, malty black tea is the backbone that the spices and milk hang on. Without enough of it the drink is just warm spiced milk.
- Fresh whole spices. Cardamom pods cracked open, fresh ginger sliced or crushed, cinnamon bark, a few cloves, a little black pepper. Ground spice from a jar loses its oils within weeks; whole spices simmered in the pot taste alive. Cardamom and ginger do most of the work.
- Milk with some body. In India it is usually whole milk, simmered with the tea rather than frothed and poured on top. The simmering is what makes a chai taste like one thing instead of two.
- Heat and sweetness in balance. Ginger and pepper give chai its warmth. Sugar rounds the bitterness of a strong steep and carries the spice. Too little sweetness and the cup is harsh; too much and it turns into dessert. The goal is a cup you could happily drink two of.
- Patience. The best chai is simmered, not dunked for a minute and strained. It is a small pot on a stove, not a tea bag.
The chai tea problem
You will see chai tea and chai tea latte on menus everywhere. Since chai means tea, the phrase says tea tea, and for a lot of people with roots in South Asia it grates. The useful distinction in an American café is between chai, the spiced tea itself, and a chai latte, which is that spiced tea made longer and creamier with steamed milk in the manner of a café latte. We use the second name on our menu because it describes what is in the cup, and we leave the extra tea off.
The dirty chai
A dirty chai is a chai latte with espresso added. The most-told version of its origin puts it in an English café in the 1990s, a shot pulled into a chai at a customer's request, though nobody has proven it. It is a strange idea on paper and a very good one in the cup: the espresso's bitterness and roast sit under the cardamom and ginger, the milk ties them together, and the result tastes like a spiced mocha with the chocolate swapped for pepper. It also adds a coffee's worth of caffeine, which is sometimes the whole point.
Ours is on the menu as a house-made dirty chai latte, hot or iced. If you have never tried one, order it hot, before you add any sugar, and taste the point where the coffee ends and the spice begins.
A good chai should taste like someone made it, not like someone pumped it.
When a chai beats a coffee
- Late afternoon. A chai built on black tea has noticeably less caffeine than a double-shot coffee, so it is the better 3 pm drink for anyone who wants to sleep that night.
- Cold weather. Ginger, cinnamon and pepper are warming in a way coffee simply is not. A hot chai on a raw day in the Rivertowns, when the wind comes off the Hudson, does something a latte cannot.
- When you want sweetness to make sense. Sugar in coffee is a correction. Sugar in chai is part of the recipe.
- With a pastry. Chai beside a butter croissant or an almond cream croissant is an easier match than coffee beside either; the spice meets the butter halfway.
- When your stomach is unhappy. Many people find ginger and milk gentler than acidic black coffee, though we would not push that claim further than our own experience.
How to order ours
The chai latte on our tea menu is listed as house-made, which is the main thing we want you to know about it, and it comes hot or iced. The chai latte is the drink itself; the dirty chai is the same drink with espresso from the bar added. Ask at the counter about oat or almond milk if you prefer them. Either way, give it a minute to cool and drink it the way the chai wallahs intend: unhurried, in company, preferably with something sweet nearby.
