Which smoothie when: matching our four smoothies to your day
A smoothie is a small decision that people make badly for the same reason every time: they pick by colour. The pink one looks like breakfast, the green one looks like virtue, and that is as far as it goes. We make four smoothies at the counter, and each one is better at some hours of the day than others. Here is how we would match them to the day you are actually having.
First, the facts that apply to all four. They are 100 percent fruit and vegetables with no added sugar. Whole fruit goes into the blender, so unlike our cold-pressed juices they keep all of their fibre. Where a recipe needs more sweetness than the fruit provides, it comes from Medjool dates, which bring their own fibre and minerals along with the sugar. Two of them are made with oat milk or no milk at all; two are made with almond milk, which matters if nuts are a concern. The full list is on our smoothies and juices page.
Breakfast on the run: Berry Burst
If you are walking down to the Tarrytown train with eleven minutes to spare, this is the one. Berry Burst is berries, banana, Medjool dates and oat milk. The berries and banana are fibre-rich and the oat milk adds a little more, so it is closer to a bowl of fruit and oats than to a glass of juice. It will hold you until lunch in a way that a pastry alone will not.
It is also the most forgiving smoothie on the list. It is made with oat milk, so there are no nuts in it, and it tastes like something you would happily drink on a Monday. If you only ever learn one of our smoothies, learn this one.
After a run or a long walk: Mango Pineapple
The aqueduct trail and the riverfront fill up with runners by eight in the morning, and a lot of them come up Main Street afterwards. Mango Pineapple is mango, pineapple, ginger, turmeric and dates, and it is the one we would hand them.
Mango and pineapple are quick carbohydrates, which is what tired muscles are looking for in the hour after exercise. Ginger and turmeric give it warmth and a faint peppery edge; people like to attach big claims to both, and we will only say that they taste good and have been eaten after exertion for a very long time. There is no milk in it at all, so it is light and bright rather than creamy, and it goes down easily when you are still warm from the run.
The 3 pm slump: Avocado Green Power
Mid-afternoon is when most people reach for sugar and regret it an hour later. Avocado Green Power is avocado, spinach, banana, dates and almond milk, and it is built differently from the other three.
The difference is fat. Avocado brings monounsaturated fat and a lot of fibre, and fat slows the whole thing down, so the sweetness from the banana and dates arrives gently and stays. It is the most filling of the four and the one least likely to send you up and then down. Spinach adds folate and iron and almost no flavour; the texture is more like a thick, cool pudding than a fruit drink. It is a late lunch when you missed lunch, and a far better bridge to dinner than a second afternoon coffee.
It contains almond milk, so it is not the one for a nut allergy.
Pick by the hour, not by the colour. The green one is not for breakfast and the pink one is not for a hot afternoon.
A grey day: Cinnamon Apple Pie
Rivertown winters bring a particular kind of low, damp afternoon, and some days call for comfort more than refreshment. Cinnamon Apple Pie is apple, banana, cinnamon, dates and almond milk, and it tastes exactly as the name suggests without a grain of added sugar.
The dates do most of the work here. Medjool dates have a caramel depth that reads as baked rather than fruity, and with cinnamon and apple the whole glass lands somewhere near the filling of a pie. Apple and banana bring the fibre, the almond milk makes it creamy, and the cinnamon gives it that warm, dessert-like finish people usually get from syrup. It is the smoothie to carry to a window table and drink slowly while the rain does whatever it is doing over the river. Note the almond milk again if nuts are an issue.
A hot afternoon: Mango Pineapple again, or Berry Burst
In July the bank building stays cool, but the sidewalk outside does not. For a hot afternoon the question is simply which one is most refreshing, and the answer is Mango Pineapple. No milk, two tropical fruits, a lift of ginger. It is the one that behaves most like a cold drink and least like a meal.
Berry Burst is the runner-up, and the better choice if you need the smoothie to also be lunch. Avocado Green Power is the wrong call on a hot day for the same reason it is the right call at 3 pm: it is rich, and richness is not what heat wants.
Kids after school: Berry Burst, with a note on nuts
Parents ask us this most. Berry Burst is the easy answer. Berries and banana are flavours children already trust, the oat milk means it is nut-free, and nothing in it needs explaining. It is sweet because fruit and dates are sweet, and it has enough fibre that it counts as a snack rather than a sugar hit.
Cinnamon Apple Pie is the other child-friendly flavour, but it is made with almond milk. If a classmate or a sibling has a nut allergy, Berry Burst is the one to order for the table. If you are unsure about anything in a recipe, ask at the counter and we will walk you through it.
Oat milk, almond milk and the nut note
Two of our smoothies are made with almond milk, one with oat milk, and one with no milk at all. Oat milk is naturally nut-free and a little creamier; almond milk is lighter and brings a faint nuttiness that suits apple and avocado. Because both are already in the kitchen for the smoothies, you can ask at the counter about oat or almond milk in other drinks too.
What none of them contain is added sugar. Every glass is sweetened by what is in it: the fruit, and where needed, the dates. That is the whole philosophy of the café in one sentence, and it is why the smoothies taste like the fruit on the label and not like the syrup on the shelf.
So: pink for the train, gold for the run, green for the slump, cinnamon for the grey days, and pink again for the children. Come find us on North Broadway and we will make whichever one your afternoon needs.
