Next workshop: Hands On Holiday Wreath Workshop, Friday, December 11 at 6 PM. See details

Coffee

Black Eye

A black eye is a cup of brewed coffee with a double shot of espresso in it. It is the next rung up from the red eye, and it exists for mornings that need more than one. It is not on our printed menu, but our espresso is a double shot already, so ask the barista whether we can drop one into a phin brew.

Black Eye

Where it comes from

The black eye is the same American coffee-shop invention as the red eye, with the dose doubled. The names are a series: one shot is a red eye, two is a black eye, three is a dead eye. Each sounds more alarming than the last, which is the joke.

Like its sibling it has no recipe beyond the obvious. It is coffee for people who have decided that enough is not enough.

A short history

The red eye family grew up in the United States once espresso machines sat beside drip pots, from the 1980s onward. The black eye followed the red eye as naturally as a second shot follows a first. In some regions the series goes by other names: shot in the dark, hammerhead, sledgehammer.

The drinks have stayed off most printed menus, which suits them. They are passed along by word of mouth, ordered by regulars, and made with a raised eyebrow.

What makes it special

A black eye is honest about what it is doing. Two shots of espresso turn a cup of coffee into something closer to a long double with brewed coffee as the base. The texture is heavier than a red eye, the flavour darker, the caffeine considerable.

Who it's for

This is for experienced coffee drinkers with a long drive, a long shift or a short night behind them. It is not for anyone caffeine-sensitive, pregnant, or hoping to sleep in the next several hours, and we would suggest a red eye first if you have never had one. For a strong black coffee with less drama, a Café Phin or a double espresso will do it.

How we make it

The black eye is not a printed menu item. Our espresso comes as a double shot and Drip Coffee is on the menu, so ask the barista to combine them; it is not a printed item, so we do not promise it is always available. Allow a few minutes for the phin to drip.

Why have it at Dahlia's Song

Because our drip coffee is the phin brew and our espresso is a double, a black eye at Dahlia's Song is about as strong as this drink gets. We will make it if we can, and we may ask whether you are sure. Drink it slowly inside the old bank on North Broadway, where the high ceiling gives it room.

Compare our coffees →

FAQ

Black Eye: questions

What is the difference between a red eye and a black eye?
One shot versus two. A black eye is brewed coffee with a double espresso in it, so it is stronger and heavier than a red eye.
How much caffeine is that?
A full cup of coffee plus a double espresso, roughly twice to three times a regular cup. It is the strongest coffee we can make.
Is there a drink with three shots?
That is a dead eye. We do not list it either; ask the barista, but we might try to talk you out of it.