Next workshop: Hands On Holiday Wreath Workshop, Friday, December 11 at 6 PM. See details

Coffee

Red Eye

A red eye is a cup of brewed coffee with a shot of espresso added. It tastes like strong coffee because it is, and the name says what it is for. It is not on our printed menu, but we brew phin coffee and pull espresso all day, so ask the barista whether we can put the two together.

Red Eye

Where it comes from

The red eye is an American drink and the name is American slang. A red-eye is an overnight flight that leaves late and lands early, and passengers come off it with the eyes to match. A coffee that could get you through the morning after became a red eye too.

There is no technique to it. Brew a cup, add a shot. It belongs to the diner counter more than the espresso bar, and it does not pretend otherwise.

A short history

Nobody has traced the first red eye. It appeared in American coffee shops once espresso machines sat beside drip pots in the 1980s and 1990s, and someone asked for both in one cup.

The name varies by region. In parts of the country it is a shot in the dark or a hammerhead; add a second shot and it becomes a black eye, a third a dead eye. The names are half the fun.

What makes it special

A red eye is honest. It does not add milk, chocolate or foam; it adds more coffee to coffee. The shot brings a syrupy, roasted depth a plain cup does not have, and the brewed coffee gives the shot room to spread out, so the result is stronger than either alone but still sippable.

Who it's for

Order a red eye if you have a long day ahead, if ordinary coffee has stopped working, or if you like your coffee very strong and black. It is one of the highest-caffeine drinks we can make, and the wrong choice for anyone caffeine-sensitive, pregnant, or planning to sleep soon. For strong without the double dose, a Café Phin alone is already a serious cup.

How we make it

The red eye is not a printed menu item. Our espresso is always on hand and Drip Coffee is on the menu, so ask the barista to combine them; it is not a printed item, so we do not promise it is always available. A phin takes a few minutes to drip, so allow for that.

Why have it at Dahlia's Song

At our counter the drip coffee is a phin brew, already thick and dark, so a red eye here is a particularly committed drink. Have it at 8 am when we open, at a table inside the old bank on North Broadway, and the rest of your Tarrytown morning will take care of itself.

Compare our coffees →

FAQ

Red Eye: questions

How much caffeine is in a red eye?
A full cup of coffee plus a shot of espresso, so roughly half again to twice what a regular cup carries. Treat it as a very high-caffeine drink.
What is the difference between a red eye and an Americano?
An Americano is espresso diluted with hot water. A red eye is espresso added to brewed coffee, so it is much stronger.
Can I order a red eye here?
Ask the barista. It is not on the printed menu, but we will put the two together when we can.